The Seductive Allure Of Neuroscience Explanations

The Seductive Allure of Neuroscience Explanations Deena Skolnick Weisberg, Frank C. Keil, Joshua Goodstein, Elizabeth Rawson, and Jeremy R. Gray Question We are always curious to understand the world we live in, and what happens around us and we often believe explanations of psychological phenomena that contains neuroscientific information without any doubt. The neuroscience information includes experiments, databases, and genetic resources. It is apparent that people seem to be more interested in explanations of psychological phenomena when it is enclosed with neuroscientific information. The study conducts experiments on whether people accepted explanations about psychological phenomena with neuroscientific information more satisfying than explanation without any neuroscientific information. The goal of this experiment was to see if neuroscience explanations have any effects on people’s rating of how satisfying they found good and bad explanations in general and those with or without neuroscientific information. The board question is why is cognitive neuroscience information so interesting to the public? Are people capable o f judging good explanations from bad explanations of psychological phenomena? The specific question is that, is people s fascination with cognitive neuroscience associated with explanations that involve neuropsychological component? Does the addition of neuroscience information to phenomena affect people s judgment of good and bad explanations?Show MoreRelatedPsychological Phenomena And Its Effects On The Perception Of Psychology Essay1497 Words   |  6 PagesPrevious research has found that the presence of irrelevant neuroscience information seems to pique the interest of the public when added to explanations of psychological phenomena. This effect of interfering with people’s ability to identify logical explanations from illogical ones does not seem to work when information from other sciences is added. We test this hypothesis by giving 340 undergraduate introductory psychology students some explanations of psychological phenomena that were from each of theRead MoreThe Effect Of Scientific Information On The Explanation Of Psychological Phenomena Essay1751 Words   |  8 Pagesresearch has shown the effect of neuroscience information in the explanation of psychological phenomena. This study aimed to replicate such findings and what effects other superfluous scientific information had on the perceived quality of explanations. 340 university students were instructed to read and evaluate a brief description on a psychological phenomenon followed by explanation of varying quality and superfluous information of various types. Good explanations were rated with a significantlyRead MoreGp Essay Mainpoints24643 Words   |  99 Pageswork and his drive for achievement†. †¢ E.g. In 1980s, two chemists claimed they had performed controlled nuclear fusion in a test tube. (energy woes solved?) But they had not performed the tests properly. †¢ E.g. Simon Shorvon (National Neuroscience Institute Chief) putting Parkinson’s disease patients through tests without informing them †¢ E.g. Tuskegee experiment (1932-1972) African American men given syphilis intentionally and monitored. Penicillin discovered then but not administered